The Verdict is in!

Today the jury in CloudofChange v. NCR returned a verdict in favor of Plaintiff CloudofChange, to the tune of $13.2 million. The jury also found NCR liable for willful infringement of the asserted patents. 

Here is where we stand thus far in Waco patent trials:

Case

Opening

Verdict

Summary

MV3 Partners LLC v.
Roku, Inc.

10/5/2020

10/14/2020

Not infringed

VLSI v. Intel Corp.

2/22/2021

3/2/2021

Infringed; not wilful; $2.175B lump-sum damages

ESW Holdings v. Roku, Inc.

4/5/2021

4/9/2021

Not infringed; 1 of 2 invalid

VLSI v. Intel Corp.

4/12/2021

4/21/2021

Not infringed; not invalid

CloudofChange, LLC v. NCR Corp.

5/17/2021

5/20/2021

Infringed; finding of wilful infringement; $13 million lump-sum damages